Confusing Local Search Intent At Google

Google rose to prominence by demonstrating a competence in discerning user intent and providing relevant search results. But this statement by Brian, a Google employee, on Google’s support forum is a bit confusing:
Today, we’re intentionally showing less local results for web design / SEO queries. For example, [web design sacramento] doesn’t display local listings today. [...]

Google rose to prominence by demonstrating a competence in discerning user intent and providing relevant search results. But this statement by Brian, a Google employee, on Google’s support forum is a bit confusing:

Today, we’re intentionally showing less local results for web design / SEO queries. For example, [web design sacramento] doesn’t display local listings today. We believe this is an accurate representation of user intent. In some cases, we do show local listings, however (as NSNA/php-er noted) [web design in bellingham]. I’m sure some of you feel we should be displaying local results for queries like [Web Design Vancouver]. I understand that concern, but based on our understanding of our users, we feel this is the right decision for now.

I have the same problem with this as Mike Blumenthal. But be sure to read the comment by David Mihm on Mike’s blog. He may have a point.

But here’s my question: At what point does spam become an issue in those other markets where web design, seo and advertising with a geo tag doesn’t pose a local search problem for Google? My guess is that will tilt against local SEOs favor as more SEOs become more savvy in Hong Kong and Mexico (and, BTW, why aren’t they that savvy in Hong Kong now?).

Is it too much to ask Google just to be forthright with the search engine optimziation community? And, furthermore, can’t Google apply more spam filters to local search results? This is something they’ve gotten good at; maybe that’s what are working on?

2010 New Year Logos from Search Engines: Yahoo, Bing, Ask.com & Google (Coming Soon)

Typically, I compile the New Years logos from the various search engines and search industry on New Years Day, but most of the search engines, with the exception of Google, have the logos out already. So here are the 2010 New Years logos. If any of them update and when Google adds there logo, I will update this post.

Google:

[Coming Soon]

Yahoo (Animated):

Yahoo (Static):

Yahoo New Years Logo

Bing:

Bing New Years Logo

Ask.com:

Ask.com New Years Logo

DogPile:

DogPile New Years Logo

Baidu:

Baidu New Years Logo

Clicker:

Clicker New Years Logo

Sogou:

Sogou New Years Logo

Cre8asite Forums:

Cre8asite Forums New Years Logo

Search Engine Roundtable (that’s us):

New Years 2010 at SERoundtable.com

For the past year’s logos, see: New Years 2009, New Years 2008, New Years 2007, Google’s 2006 logo, Search Engine Roundtable’s 2006 logo, Ask’s 2005 logo, and Cre8asite’s 2005.

Forum discussion currently at Search Engine Roundtable Forums, Bing Forums.


Typically, I compile the New Years logos from the various search engines and search industry on New Years Day, but most of the search engines, with the exception of Google, have the logos out already. So here are the 2010 New Years logos. If any of them update and when Google adds there logo, I will update this post.

Google:

[Coming Soon]

Yahoo (Animated):

Yahoo (Static):

Yahoo New Years Logo

Bing:

Bing New Years Logo

Ask.com:

Ask.com New Years Logo

DogPile:

DogPile New Years Logo

Baidu:

Baidu New Years Logo

Clicker:

Clicker New Years Logo

Sogou:

Sogou New Years Logo

Cre8asite Forums:

Cre8asite Forums New Years Logo

Search Engine Roundtable (that’s us):

New Years 2010 at SERoundtable.com

For the past year’s logos, see: New Years 2009, New Years 2008, New Years 2007, Google’s 2006 logo, Search Engine Roundtable’s 2006 logo, Cre8asite’s 2005.

Forum discussion currently at Search Engine Roundtable Forums, Bing Forums.



2010 New Year Logos from Search Engines: Yahoo, Bing, Ask.com & Google

Typically, I compile the New Years logos from the various search engines and search industry on New Years Day, but most of the search engines, with the exception of Google, have the logos out already. So here are the 2010 New Years logos. If any of them update and when Google adds there logo, I will update this post.

Google:

Google New Years 2010

Yahoo (Animated):

Yahoo (Static):

Yahoo New Years Logo

Bing:

Bing New Years Logo

AOL:

AOL New Years Theme

Ask.com:

Ask.com New Years Logo

DogPile:

DogPile New Years Logo

Baidu:

Baidu New Years Logo

Clicker:

Clicker New Years Logo

Sogou:

Sogou New Years Logo

Zuula:

Zuula New Years Logo

Cre8asite Forums:

Cre8asite Forums New Years Logo

Search Engine Roundtable (that’s us):

New Years 2010 at SERoundtable.com

For the past year’s logos, see: New Years 2009, New Years 2008, New Years 2007, Google’s 2006 logo, Search Engine Roundtable’s 2006 logo, Ask’s 2005 logo, and Cre8asite’s 2005.

Forum discussion currently at Search Engine Roundtable Forums, Bing Forums, HighRankings Forums, Google Webmaster Help, WebmasterWorld and Cre8asite Forums.


Update: Remember the I’m Feeling Lucky Google Countdown feature? Well, at midnight, when you click it, this is what it looks like: Via websonic.nl


Typically, I compile the New Years logos from the various search engines and search industry on New Years Day, but most of the search engines, with the exception of Google, have the logos out already. So here are the 2010 New Years logos. If any of them update and when Google adds there logo, I will update this post.

Google:

Google New Years 2010

Yahoo (Animated):

Yahoo (Static):

Yahoo New Years Logo

Bing:

Bing New Years Logo

AOL:

AOL New Years Theme

Ask.com:

Ask.com New Years Logo

DogPile:

DogPile New Years Logo

Baidu:

Baidu New Years Logo

Clicker:

Clicker New Years Logo

Sogou:

Sogou New Years Logo

Zuula:

Zuula New Years Logo

Cre8asite Forums:

Cre8asite Forums New Years Logo

Search Engine Roundtable (that’s us):

New Years 2010 at SERoundtable.com

For the past year’s logos, see: New Years 2009, New Years 2008, New Years 2007, Google’s 2006 logo, Search Engine Roundtable’s 2006 logo, Cre8asite’s 2005.

Forum discussion currently at Search Engine Roundtable Forums, Bing Forums, HighRankings Forums, Google Webmaster Help, WebmasterWorld and Cre8asite Forums.


Update: Remember the I’m Feeling Lucky Google Countdown feature? Well, at midnight, when you click it, this is what it looks like: Via websonic.nl



WebmasterWorld’s Tabke: Google “Stiffed” Webmasters on Christmas

Yesterday we reported that Google donated $20 million to charity instead of giving out their typical holiday gifts to publishers. We initially thought Google would not send out gifts this year, and we were somewhat right. They did not give publishers, advertisers or webmasters anything really – outside of what they earned.

Brett Tabke, the owner of WebmasterWorld, commented in a WebmasterWorld thread with his true feelings. He felt Google stiffed webmasters, advertisers and publishers this year. Let me quote him:

Lets get real. A $20m tax write off to charity has nothing to do with AdSense or AdWords swag gifts. If you were expecting a gift from Google – you got stiffed. Your “gift” did not go to charity. If it did go to charity in your name, then ask Google for documentation to that effect so that you can take it off your taxes. To even mention the two in the same breath is a disservice to the charities and to AdSense operators. Google gives money every year to charity – so do alot of businesses. $20 million isn’t even good pocket changes to google. These two events are totally unrelated. Nothing but political pr slight-of-hand at work.

Do you agree with this?

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.


Yesterday we reported that Google donated $20 million to charity instead of giving out their typical holiday gifts to publishers. We initially thought Google would not send out gifts this year, and we were somewhat right. They did not give publishers, advertisers or webmasters anything really – outside of what they earned.

Brett Tabke, the owner of WebmasterWorld, commented in a WebmasterWorld thread with his true feelings. He felt Google stiffed webmasters, advertisers and publishers this year. Let me quote him:

Lets get real. A $20m tax write off to charity has nothing to do with AdSense or AdWords swag gifts. If you were expecting a gift from Google – you got stiffed. Your “gift” did not go to charity. If it did go to charity in your name, then ask Google for documentation to that effect so that you can take it off your taxes. To even mention the two in the same breath is a disservice to the charities and to AdSense operators. Google gives money every year to charity – so do alot of businesses. $20 million isn’t even good pocket changes to google. These two events are totally unrelated. Nothing but political pr slight-of-hand at work.

Do you agree with this?

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.



Buy a Banned Domain? Should You Ask Google for Forgiveness?

A WebmasterWorld thread has one webmaster who allegedly purchased a domain name that was banned by Google. He basically asked, how does he get this domain to be clean and start over.

In the past, I would have said, just submit a reconsideration request and hope that Google trusts that you are starting new. And that is the advice given in the thread.

But after sitting in a site clinic with Matt Cutts at PubCon. At about 10:51 PST, Matt said that when it comes to domains that were banned or severely penalized, it is just easier to start with a fresh new domain. I am not quoting Matt exactly, but he basically said that it is easier to start from ground zero then starting from 100 feet under ground. Yes, a penalized site seems to just have to work its way up from a negative state to get to level starting ground and often, it might not be worth the effort.

At the same time, if Google can press a button to wipe the history of the domain – then maybe you are in luck. I am just not too sure how easy it is to get Google to do that.

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.


A WebmasterWorld thread has one webmaster who allegedly purchased a domain name that was banned by Google. He basically asked, how does he get this domain to be clean and start over.

In the past, I would have said, just submit a reconsideration request and hope that Google trusts that you are starting new. And that is the advice given in the thread.

But after sitting in a site clinic with Matt Cutts at PubCon. At about 10:51 PST, Matt said that when it comes to domains that were banned or severely penalized, it is just easier to start with a fresh new domain. I am not quoting Matt exactly, but he basically said that it is easier to start from ground zero then starting from 100 feet under ground. Yes, a penalized site seems to just have to work its way up from a negative state to get to level starting ground and often, it might not be worth the effort.

At the same time, if Google can press a button to wipe the history of the domain – then maybe you are in luck. I am just not too sure how easy it is to get Google to do that.

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.



Google: “Who Is The Failure”? President Obama & White House

Ask Google who is the failure and you will see Google showing the first result as whitehouse.gov/administration/president-obama.

Who Is The Failure

Yes, a “Google Bomb” on President Obama and the White House. Google has to run their bomb defuse algorithm, which by the way has two algorithms to fix this issue. Just like they did for miserable failure and failure bombs.

The best place to see all the history on these types of presidential Google Bombs is at Search Engine Land.

This search was first sent to me last week by @suzukik.

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.


Ask Google who is the failure and you will see Google showing the first result as whitehouse.gov/administration/president-obama.

Who Is The Failure

Yes, a “Google Bomb” on President Obama and the White House. Google has to run their bomb defuse algorithm, which by the way has two algorithms to fix this issue. Just like they did for miserable failure and failure bombs.

The best place to see all the history on these types of presidential Google Bombs is at Search Engine Land.

This search was first sent to me last week by @suzukik.

Forum discussion at WebmasterWorld.



Seth Godin: Sliced Bread

Malcolm Gladwell: Outliers

Anthony Parinello: Your Price is Too High